Can paint-only bike lanes actually increase accidents?

On Behalf of | Oct 17, 2023 | Bike Accidents |

According to Wired, Washington state is the most friendly and safe for bicyclists, but every state can make strides to keep bikes safer on the roads.

Bike lanes have become an integral part of urban infrastructure, aiming to create safer environments for cyclists and promote eco-friendly transportation. However, a contentious debate centers on whether paint-only bike lanes, as opposed to more substantial physical barriers, can inadvertently increase accident rates.

Benefits of paint-only lanes

Advocates of paint-only bike lanes argue that they are cost-effective and relatively easy to implement. These lanes involve painting lines on the road, and they offer a designated space for cyclists to ride safely. When cost is a concern, this is a great solution that works for everyone.

Concerns about paint-only lanes

One of the main concerns regarding paint-only bike lanes is that they lack physical protection for cyclists. Without physical barriers like curbs, bollards or planters, these lanes rely solely on painted lines to separate cyclists from vehicular traffic. This lack of separation can lead to issues such as dooring incidents, where a driver or passenger opens a car door in the path of an oncoming cyclist or illegal parking or stopping in the bike lane.

Additionally, vehicles can sometimes encroach into the bike lane. When a bike lane has only paint markings, motorists may be less inclined to respect it.

Furthermore, there’s an argument that paint-only bike lanes may create a false sense of security for both cyclists and drivers. Cyclists might assume they are safer in a bike lane, while drivers might be less vigilant about looking for cyclists outside of these designated areas. This can lead to a higher risk of accidents at intersections and other conflict points.

Research into the matter

Research on the relationship between paint-only bike lanes and accident rates is not definitive. Studies have produced mixed results, and it is challenging to draw broad conclusions due to the influence of various factors, including local road conditions, traffic patterns and the design of specific bike lanes.

Ultimately, the effectiveness of paint-only bike lanes in increasing or decreasing accident rates can vary significantly. Properly designed and well-maintained paint-only bike lanes might enhance cyclist safety by providing a designated space on the road. However, the absence of physical barriers may undermine their effectiveness in certain situations.


FindLaw Network